Haunted Homes and Eerie Estates: Ontario’s Spookiest Real Estate Secrets
If walls could talk, some Ontario homes would whisper chilling tales of mystery, misfortune, and the downright macabre. With Halloween creeping in, it’s the perfect time to take a ghostly stroll through some of Ontario’s most haunted properties - where real estate meets real-life horror stories. Whether you’re a history buff, a supernatural skeptic, or just love a good scare, these spooky sites will keep you up at night.
1. The Hermitage Ruins – Ancaster, Ontario
Once a grand mansion, The Hermitage was home to Otto Ives, a British officer, and his niece, whom he forbade from marrying a coachman. Legend says the heartbroken suitor hanged himself on the property. Today, only the stone shell of the mansion remains, but visitors report hearing whispers, footsteps, and ghostly figures roaming the ruins. Real estate tip: This isn’t for sale - but the nearby Ancaster area offers some beautiful historic homes (without the ghosts).
2. The Screaming Tunnel – Niagara-on-the-Lake
Okay, not a home, but it was part of a larger estate. The legend goes that a young girl, trapped in a fire, died screaming in this limestone tunnel. Today, if you light a match at midnight, she’s said to scream from beyond. Local insight: Niagara-on-the-Lake is known for its charming colonial homes and quiet streets. Just maybe avoid tunnels after dark.
3. Gibraltar Point Lighthouse – Toronto Islands
Built in 1808, this is Toronto’s oldest lighthouse - and one of its most haunted spots. The lighthouse keeper, John Paul Radelmüller, was murdered by soldiers, and his body buried nearby. His spirit is said to still climb the stairs of the tower, never resting. Urban legend bonus: Some downtown Toronto heritage buildings, especially in Cabbagetown and the Annex, have their own haunted histories too.
4. Baldoon Mystery House – Wallaceburg
In the 1830s, the McDonald family home became the site of what’s now called the Baldoon Mystery. Fires erupted from nowhere, bullets bounced off walls, and objects flew across rooms - until a local woman told them to shoot a black-headed goose. The haunting stopped. Coincidence? Fun fact: The area remains peaceful today, with farmhouses and country properties that are far more relaxing than cursed.
5. Keg Mansion – Toronto, ON
Now a steakhouse, this Victorian mansion once belonged to industrialist Hart Massey. After his daughter’s death, a grieving maid took her own life in the home. Diners report eerie cold spots, flickering lights, and footsteps where no one walks. Real estate note: The Gothic Revival style is still popular with Toronto buyers - just maybe with fewer spirits.
6. Bytown Museum – Ottawa
Located next to the Rideau Canal, this building has reports of moving objects, ghost sightings, and strange noises. Once a home and office for Colonel John By (the canal’s engineer), the museum preserves both local history and its haunts. Ottawa buyers: Heritage homes in Sandy Hill or the Glebe offer similar charm, minus the apparitions.
7. The Ghost Road – Port Perry
Behind this sleepy town is a haunted stretch of road where a ghostly motorcyclist chases visitors. Legend says he crashed decades ago and never left. Nighttime visitors report red lights and engine sounds out of nowhere. Buyers beware: Port Perry is full of lakeside gems - but maybe bring a flashlight.
Would You Buy a Haunted House?
Believe it or not, some buyers want the haunted vibes. Historic homes, especially century-old Victorians, carry character and stories you can’t replicate. But Ontario law doesn’t require sellers to disclose paranormal activity - so if ghost stories matter to you, ask before you sign.
The Rocca Sisters Team knows Burlington, Hamilton, Oakville, and surrounding areas inside and out - even the homes with a little history. Whether you want a cozy cottage or a (ghost-free) Gothic revival, we’ll help you find your perfect match - spirit or no spirit.
Come Trick-or-Treat at the Rocca Sisters Office
Before you head out ghost-hunting, join us for some Halloween fun. Bring your little ghosts and goblins to the Rocca Sisters office on Thursday, October 31st, between 11:00 a.m. and 8:00 p.m. for a day of community trick-or-treating.
Location: Rocca Sisters Office, 530 Brant Street, Burlington
Stop by for candy, photos, and some festive fun with our team.
Happy Haunting.
– The Rocca Sisters Team
Posted by Tanya Rocca on
Leave A Comment